The Law Commission of England and Wales, an independent entity responsible for reviewing and recommending reforms in the legal sphere, has made a significant proposal regarding the classification of crypto assets. In its latest report, the Commission advocates for these digital assets to be recognized as a unique form of personal property under English law.
Current Legal Framework and Its Limitations
Under the current legal framework, English law distinguishes personal property into two primary categories: things in possession (tangible property) and things in action (intangible property, such as debts or rights). However, this traditional dichotomy has proven inadequate for addressing the complexities associated with digital assets like cryptocurrencies and non-fungible tokens (NFTs). These assets often exhibit characteristics of both tangible and intangible properties, leading to challenges in dispute resolution during legal proceedings.
The Need for a Third Category
To resolve these ambiguities and better cater to the unique nature of digital assets, the Law Commission has proposed the creation of a “third category” of personal property. This new category would specifically address the hybrid qualities of digital assets, ensuring that property rights associated with them are both clear and enforceable. The Commission believes that the flexibility of common law is conducive to recognizing this distinct category, which would significantly enhance the legal recognition and protection of digital assets.
“We conclude that the flexibility of common law allows for the recognition of a distinct category of personal property that can better recognize, accommodate, and protect the unique features of certain digital assets (including crypto-tokens and crypto-assets),” the report states.
Draft Bill and Its Implications
Accompanying the recommendation, the Commission has issued a draft bill that outlines the framework for this new property category. The draft bill delegates the responsibility to the courts to further develop and refine this third category as necessary, allowing for future amendments without disrupting the legal status of other forms of personal property.
Government and Regulatory Response
The proposal and the draft bill are currently under consideration by the government. Meanwhile, the Bank of England and the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) have recently launched a consultation on draft guidance for their Digital Securities Sandbox. This sandbox is intended to facilitate the testing of distributed ledger technology (DLT) in the trading and settlement of digital securities, such as shares and bonds, highlighting the government’s interest in adapting regulatory frameworks to accommodate emerging technologies.
| Feature | Description | Legal Impact |
|---|---|---|
| New Property Category | Creation of a third category for crypto assets | Clarifies and enforces property rights |
| Draft Bill | Outlines legal framework for new category | Guides courts in developing law |
| Regulatory Sandbox | Testing of DLT in securities trading | Supports innovation in financial tech |
The Law Commission’s initiative marks a pivotal step in adapting legal structures to the evolving landscape of digital assets. By proposing a dedicated category for crypto assets, the Commission aims to provide a more robust legal foundation that supports the growth and stability of the digital assets sector in England and Wales. This development is a clear indicator of the legal community’s recognition of the need for greater clarity and protection in the realm of digital property.
